These alternative nut butters provide a tasty alternative to peanut butter. While peanut butter has long been a pantry staple, many consumers are interested in trying more exotic toast toppers. With so many options to choose from, consumers now have a number of different ways to switch up their favorite breakfast spread.
In recent years, many brands have started producing condiments that are safe for those with peanut allergies. These alternative nut butters are generally made from almonds, hazelnuts and even cashews. Some of these peanut-free spreads include organic cashew butter, coconut-infused almond butters and hazelnut-based coffee butters.
There are also peanut-based spreads for those who love peanut butter, but want to add a little variety to their favorite foods. These condiments put a fun twist on conventional peanut butter by adding healthy ingredients and unexpected flavors. Some of these innovative peanut spreads include superfood-infused peanut butters, boozy peanut pastes and high-protein sandwich spreads.
28 Alternative Nut Butters

28
Dessert-Inspired Almond Spreads
Buff Bake's Almond Butter Spread Tastes Like Birthday Cake

27
GMO-Free Junk Food
The UNREAL Candies Boast a List of Healthy Ingredients That Others Cannot
26
Omega-Rich Peanut Spreads
This SmartFruit Product Combines Peanut Butter and Omega from Flax
25
Superfood-Infused Peanut Butter
This Chia Seed Spread is Great in Baking, Smoothies or Bread
24
Chocolate Peanut Butters
The New Reese's Spread is Going to Change How We Eat Almost All Food
23
Nourishing Nut Butter
YumButter's Superfood Snacks Come in Squeezable Pouches
22
Exotic Sandwich Toppings
Frolic Kitchen Makes an Ambitious Range of Flavored Peanut Butters
21
Hazelnut Coffee Butters
This Organic Spread from Rodale's is Decadent and All Natural
20
Nourishing Multi-Nut Spreads
'NuttZo' Products are Made with a Blend of Seven Nuts and Seeds
19
Artisan Nut Butter Sets
This Eliot's Nut Butter Three-Pack Includes Their Honey Chipotle PB
18
High-Protein Sandwich Spreads
These Healthy Spreads Contain a Hearty Serving of Protein
17
Coconut-Infused Almond Butters
This DIY Nut Butter is a Delicious and Nutritious Treat
16
Nutty Superfood Spreads
New York Superfoods' Healthy Peanut Butter Includes Crunchy Chia Seeds
15
Iconic-Coco Spreads
The Three New Hershey’s Chocolate Spreads are a Delight to the Senses
14
Flavorful Soybean Spreads
Don't Go Nuts Make Nut-Free Spreads in Chocolate, Cinnamon and More
13
Homemade Nut Butters
This DIY Coconut Butter Preserves Flavor and Cuts Down on Cost
12
Caffeinated Peanut Butter Packs
The PROBAR Organic Peanut Butter Blend is Infused with Yerba Matte
11
Remixed Gourmet Nut Butter
Better Off Butter Spreads Make You Look at Peanut Butter Differently
10
Watermelon Seed Butter
This Sakara Product is an Alternative to Common Nut and Seed Spreads
9
Pistachio Puree Spreads
This Nut Spread from the Pinar Dairy Company is a Butter Alternative
8
Organic Nut Butters
These Elegantly Packaged Butters Use Watercolor Images of Each Nut Flavor
7
Micronutrient Nut Butters
The Barney Butter Almond Butter is Flavored with Honey and Flax Seeds
6
Crunchy Almond Spreads
Barney Butter Offers an Alternative to Smooth Almond Nut Butter
5
Boozy Peanut Spreads
Reginald's Peanut Butter Spread is Infused with Bourbon and Pecans
4
Craft Organic Nut Butters
The Crowdfunded Natural Peanut Butter is Made With Love and Reggae Music
3
Caramel Peanut Butter
Skippy Brings Decadence to Snacktime with a Salted Caramel Infusion
2
Chipotle Honey Spreads
This Chipotle Honey Almond Butter Refashions Traditional Breakfast Routines
1
Wok-Fried Peanut Butter Tutorials
Alton Brown Can Teach You How to Make Homemade Peanut Butter
Related Ideas
Crispy Peanut Butter Bars
Skippy Peanut Butter Wafer Bars Satisfy Snackers with a Sweet Crunch
Sandwich-Inspired Peanut Butter Cups
Reese's PB&J Big Cups Come in Two Flavors
Hazelnut Spread Baked Goods
Nutella Donuts Arrive This Month with a Rich Taste and Texture
Plant-Made Hazelnut Spreads
Ferrero is Set to Unveil the New Plant-Based Chocolate Hazelnut Spread
Seed Oil-Free Snacks
Wild Fox Foods Makes Clean, Protein-Packed Snacks Without Refined Sugar
Jammy Superfood Bites
Chia Smash's Natural Smash Bites are Loaded with Texture, Flavor & Protein
Organic Plant-Based Protein Bars
Kate’s Real Food Has Expanded Its Product Lineup
Globally Inspired Nut Snacks
Octonuts Focuses on Cashew-Based Snacks and Butters
Low-Sugar Crunch Bars
Krack’d Snacks' Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Caramel Crunch is Vegan
Nutty Banana Granola Clusters
KIND Healthy Grains Banana Peanut Butter Clusters are Whole Grain
Chili Crisp Butters
Butt Co.'s Spicy Grass-Fed Butter Adds a Kick to Favorite Meals and Snacks
Flavored Cashew Snacks
Octonuts Partnered with rePurpose Global to Combat Ocean Waste
Keto-Friendly Vegan Chocolates
Krack'd Snacks Mylk Chocolate Peanut Butter Caramel Crunch is Keto
Creamy Milk-Free Chocolates
Fellow Creatures Recreates Milk Chocolate Without Dairy
Crunchy Peanut Butter Snacks
Justin's Expands Its Line-Up with Two New Decadent Offerings
Maple Butter Breakfast Sandwiches
Starbucks Has Added a New Chicken, Maple Butter & Egg Sandwich
Sugar-Conscious Snack Bars
The Unreal Dark Chocolate Caramel Peanut Nougat Bars are Non-GMO
Nutty Ice Cream Sandwiches
M&M's Peanut Butter Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich Comes in Two Formats
Peanut-Based Beverages
Bonneterre's New Drink is Plant-Based and Organic
Nutty Viral Chocolate-Inspired Spreads
Amoretti Pistachio Cream Has a Versatile Profile
Peanut Butter Potato Cookies
Skippy is Returning to Canada with All-New Peanut Butter Snacks
Shelf Stable Milk Alternatives
MALK Organics' New Product Lineup Features Three New Beverages
Hot Honey Breakfast Sandwiches
Dunkin' is Adding a New Hot Honey Bacon Sandwich for a Limited Time
Decadent Nut-Based Snacks
The Realsy Nut Butter Dates are Nutrient-Dense On-the-Go Snacks
Bean-Based Chocolate Alternatives
Nukoko Makes a Cocoa-Free Chocolate Alternative from Fava Beans
Chocolate Hazelnut Offerings
The Tim Hortons x Nutella Collab Features Six Decadent Items
Brain-Boosting Nut Spreads
Hank's Brain Boosting Peanut Spread is Made with Phospholipid Protein
Supercharged Canned Cold Brews
Unconform Combines Arabica Coffee, Oat Milk and Nootropics
Apple-Based Honey Alternatives
Langer Farms Has Introduced Two Plant-Based Products
Creamy Eggnog-Infused Whiskeys
Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey Eggnog Returns for the Holidays
Sweetly Nutty Coffee Ranges
Little's Coffee Toffee Nut Comes in Instant and Capsules
Peanut Butter Dessert Jars
Jar Joy's Peanut Butter Cup Jars are Viral TikTok Desserts
Childhood Cereal Nut Butters
Fit Butters Cashew Butter Partnered with Post Cereal
Dairy-Free Chocolate Berry Creamers
Chocolate Strawberry Almond Creamer is a Valentine's Treat
Sustainability-Focused Nut Butters
The ManiLife Almond Butter Range is Arriving in the UK
Indulgent Peanut Butter Treats
Drumstick Launched its Novel 'We Love Peanut Butter' Pack
Peanut Butter-Inspired Protein Bars
Genius Gourmet Partners with SKIPPY® Peanut Butter
Bean-Free Coffee Alternatives
Voyage Foods Launched Bean-Free Coffee for Foodservice Clients
Spreadable Health-Conscious Butters
This New Challenge Spreadable Butter Product Has Canola Oil
Low-Cost Cocoa Powder Alternatives
Cocoa Butter Buds is a Cost-Effective Option to Cocoa Powder
Fermented Vegan Cashew Dips
Nuts For Cheese Creamy Cashew Dips Come in Three Flavors
Mesquite-Based Bars
Mez's Un-Chocolate Bars are Abundant in Protein and Cocoa-Free
Brown Butter Cubes
Buji Brown Butter Adds Richness and Nutty Flavor to Sweet & Savory Recipes
Sweet Pickle Dips
Plucky Pickle Dip's Two New Dips Blend Cream Cheese & White Beans
Organic Nut-Based Candies
Justin's Launched Certified Organic Peanut Chocolate Candy Pieces
Savory Seasonal Menus
Paris Baguette Unveiled a New 2025 Menu Featuring Butter Pecan Pastries
QSR Organic Nut Pouches
Clif Family is Offering Two New Seasoned Nut Flavors In-Stores
Healthy Chocolate-Hazelnut Cereals
Surreal's Zero-Sugar Choc Hazelnut Cereal is Protein-Packed
Better-For-You Peanut Butter Cups
Simply Peanut Butter Crispies Were Created with Whole Foods
Plant-Based Filled Chocolates
Thro's Filled Chocolates are Salty, Sweet Multi-Textured Indulgences
Allergy-Friendly Mayo Spreads
Fabalish's Soy-Free Vegan Mayo is Made with Chickpea Water
Nutty Oat-Rich Protein Bars
Kate's Real Food Peanut Butter Cup Protein Bar is Honey-Sweetened
Crunchy-Sweet Condiments
Schmutz's Haroset Turns a Passover Essential into an Everyday Spread
Salty-Sweet Nut Snacks
SkinnyDipped Salty + Sweet Helps Snackers Avoid Sugar Hangovers
Honey-Infused Peanut Butters
Trader Joe's Peanut Butter with Honey is Made with Just 3 Ingredients
Nostalgic Salted Caramel Bars
Salted Caramel Butterfinger® Marks a Significant Milestone
Protein Peanut Butters
FitFeast's Peanut Butter is Dessert-Like and Sweetened with Honey or Dates
Sandwich-Inspired Pretzel Snacks
Quinn PB&J Berry Pretzel Nuggets Have a Classic Flavor Profile
THC-Infused Honeys
butter Collaborated with Bees in the D and Hunna on a Limited-Edition Edible
Decadent Peanut Butter Treats
The Kraft Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Thins are Bite-Size Snacks
Dog-Friendly Peanut Butter Bites
Milk-Bone x Jif Peanut Butter Treats Dogs to Nutty, Bacony Flavor
Nutty Nostalgic Baked Goods
The Crumbl Peanut Butter Dessert Bar is a New Take on a Classic
Southern-Inspired Peanut Snacks
Dixie Grace’s Boiled Peanuts Have Seven-Grams of Protein
Dairy-Free Hazelnut Spreads
Nutella Plant-Based has Chickpeas and Rice Syrup in Place of Milk
Hot Honey Almond Snacks
Blue Diamond Mike’s Hot Honey Almonds are Sweet, Spicy and Crunchy
Alternative Oat Butters
Miyoko’s Oat Milk Butter Comes in Sweet and Savory Varieties
Sweetly Spreadable Butters
Kerrygold Sweet Spreadables Come in Three Flavor Options
Hot Honey Nut Butters
Nutty Novelties' Habanero Honey Peanut Butter is Sweet and Spicy
Flavor-Packed Peanut Snacks
These ManiLife Peanut Snacks Come in 25-Gram Packs
Liqueur-Branded Nut Mixes
These New Baileys Nut Mixes Come in Two Recipes
Spiced Collaboration Nut Snacks
The Snak Club x Hot Ones Roasted Nuts Come in Two Flavors
Hazelnut Spread Baked Goods
The Paris Baguette Nutella Menu Includes Five Options
Mushroom-Infused Nut Butters
Bear Butter's Almond Butter is Enhanced with Foraged Mushrooms
Better-for-You Restaurant Spreads
bettergoods' Cinnamon Honey Butter is a Dupe for Texas Roadhouse
Better-For-You Peanut Butter Cups
Superfoodio Debuts the Peanut Butter Better Cups
Keto-Friendly Peanut Butter Snacks
No Sugar Company Introduces the Peanut Butter Keto Shellz
Honey-Infused Energy Waffles
Honey Stinger Peanut Butter Energy Waffles Come in Three Flavors
Honey-Sesame Snack Bars
A Traditional Greek Snack Inspired Beeyond Snacks' Honey & Sesame Bars
Nutty Cookie-Inspired Granolas
Purely Elizabeth Peanut Butter Cookie Granola is Snacking-Friendly
Nutty High-Protein Oats
Quaker Protein Peanut Butter is Flavorful and Satisfying
Bean-Based Pancake Mixes
Full of Beans Makes Pancake and Waffle Mix with Fava Bean Flour
Collaboration Candy Popcorn Kits
This Popcorn Kitchen x Superfoodio Kit is Sweet and Nutty
Plant-Based Peanut Butter Cups
The 7th Heaven Oat Milk Peanut Butter Cups are Dairy-Free
Plant-Based Protein Cookies
Made with Local Introduced its Protein Nut Butter Cookies
Peanut Butter-Packed Chocolate Cups
SkinnyDipped Topless Peanut Butter Cups are Low in Sugar
Chocolatey British Butters
All Things Butter Chocolate is Made with 100% British Cream
Bite-Sized Brûlée Cups
Feve Chocolates' Brûlée Cups Offer an Elevated Take on the Nut Butter Cup
Spicy Butter Spreads
Popup Bagels x Frank's RedHot Collaborated on a Spicy Schmear
Hard Shell Peanut Candies
Trader Joe's Peanut Butter Pillows Boasts a Crispy Candy Exterior
Crunchy Free-From Snack Mixes
Absurd Snacks Nut-Free Snack Mixes are Free From the Top Nine
Travel-Safe Snackable Sandwiches
Rudi's Launched Nut-Free Sandos with a Creamy Roasted Seed Spread
Hot Cocoa-Flavored Cashews
Planters' Toasted Marshmallow Hot Chocolate Cashews are Limited-Edition
Buttery Cold Cafe Drinks
PJ's Coffee Southern Butter Pecan Drinks Come in Two Options
Chocolatey Peanut Butter Spreads
Jif Peanut Butter & Chocolate Spread Comes in Two Sizes
Candy Bar-Infused Cream Cheeses
PopUp Bagels is Launching a Limited-Edition Butterfinger Shmear
Extra-Creamy Peanut Butter Alternatives
CRAVE P’Not Butter is Made with Sunflower Seeds
Flavored Grass-Fed Butters
Churn Elevates Meals Made at Home with Flavors like Miso & Pesto
Sandwich-Inspired Crepe Snacks
bakerly peanut butter and grape filled crêpes to-go are Flavorful
Ghee-Roasted Granolas
Panjiri Granola by Babo's Kitchen Has an Unconventional First Ingredient
Gum-Free Pecan Milks
PKN Zero Pecan Milk Has a Buttery Texture and Roasted Flavor
Squeezable Caramel Nut Butters
Whole Earth Peanut Butter Salted Caramel Drizzler is Extra-Rich
Protein-Rich Vegan Candy Bars
Barebells Caramel Peanut Boasts 15-Grams of Plant Protein
Free-From Dippable Snacks
Sunnie's Jam Dipper is a Clean Reinvention of a Childhood Treat
Soft Brittle Snacks
Tam’s Sweets Makes Decadent Treats That Differ from Traditional Hard Brittle
Minimal-Ingredient Chocolate Almonds
Unreal's Covered Almonds are Simple, Non-Waxy and Mess-Free
Minimal-Ingredient Cashew Creamers
Elmhurst 1925 Developed the First Cashew-Based Creamers
Buttery Peanut Brittle Candies
Trader Joe's Peanut Brittle is Made by an English Confectioner
Single-Serve Sweet Sandwiches
Once Again Chocolate & Peanut Butter Graham Sandwiches are Tasty
Gluten-Free Graham Crackers
Once Again is Lunching New Gluten-Free Graham Crackers
Mixable Egg Alternatives
Altro Food Makes Plant-Based Eggs with Pea Proteins & Lentil Flour
Protein-Enhanced Peanut Butters
Whole Earth Protein Crunch Peanut Butter Has Pea Protein Pieces
Crustless Berry Sandwiches
Peanut Butter & Raspberry is Uncrustables' First New Flavor in 10 Years
Japanese-Style Peanut Snacks
Trader Joe's Crispy Crunchy Coated Peanuts are Highly Addictive
Organic Peanut Butter Cereals
Trader Joe's Just Added Organic Peanut Butter & Cocoa Crunch Cereal
Brunch-Inspired Cashews
Yupik's Bloody Mary Cashews are Crispy, Savory and Bold
Peanut Butter Baking Chips
These Peanut Butter Flavored Baking Chips are Cookie Dough-Ready
Modern Peanut Butter Packets
One Trick Pony's Single Serve Squeeze Packs Boast Playful Packaging
Bee-Free Hot Honey Sandwiches
Neat's Hot Honey Sando is Made with Mellody Spicy Habanero
Simple Recipe Spreadable Butters
The Latest Kerrygold Spreadable Butter Has Two Ingredients
Creamy Chickpea-Based Spreads
The NIÚKE VMAYO Mayo-Inspired Spreads Come in Eight Flavors
THC-Infused Chocolate Hazelnut Spreads
butter's Chocolate Hazelnut Spread Has an Adult Twist
DIY Nut Milk Kits
Nutterie's Range of Nut Milk Boxes Encourages Creativity in the Kitchen
Almond Butter Protein Smoothies
This Banana & Almond Butter Protein Smoothie Boasts 14g of Protein
Dual Nut Snacks
Planters Nut Duos Combine Two Flavors and Two Different Nut Types in a Bag
Charcuterie-Inspired Nut Snacks
The Columbus Craft Nuts Come in Four Foodie-Inspired Flavors
Low-Sugar Hazelnut Cocoa Spreads
Gooey Was Developed with AI to Fill an Unmet Consumer Need
Better-for-You Hazelnut Spreads
Chosen Foods Chocolate Hazelnut Spread Has 100% Avocado Oil
Artisan Ingredient Marketplaces
Nutterie Offers Nuts, Seeds, Dried Fruits and Artisan Snack Mixes
Peanut Butter-Packed Snack Bars
Pip & Nut Peanut Butter Stuffed Oat Bars Come in Three Flavors
Grab-and-Go Peanut Snacks
The KP Snack Packs Honey Roast Peanuts Come in Five-Serving Multipacks
Summery Butter Pecan Beverages
PJ's Coffee is Serving Up a New Butter Pecan Velvet Ice Drink
Nutty Chocolate Toothpastes
Hismile's Hazelnut Spread Toothpaste Features Rich, Roasted Flavors
Allergen-Free Seed Butters
Sowleil's Allergy-Friendly Butters are Arriving on the Market
Nut-Based Ricotta Alternatives
Dreamfarm Crafts Vegan Ricotta with Almonds and Cashews
Indulgent Collaboration Cakes
Nothing Bundt Cakes Reese's Chocolate Peanut Butter is Rich
Red Bean-Flavored Toast Spreads
Bourbon Nosete Yaku An Butter Sheets are Easy to Use
Richly Flavored Peanut Butters
Proper Nutty Dark Roast Peanut Butter Boasts an Intense Taste
Versatile Gluten-Free Granolas
Lizi's Caramelised Almonds, Hazelnuts & Pecans Granola is Tasty
Flavorful Southern Peanut Snacks
Dixie Grace's Boiled Peanuts are Made with Four Ingredients
Modern Gourmet Peanut Brand
Hubbard Peanut Company's Peanuts are an Excellent Gift Option